Enter to win a copy of Devil's Hand!
***
Lessons I’ve Learned From Early Readers
by M. E. Patterson
It’s easy, when you’re first getting started in the whole writing game, to assume that you’re “pretty darn good at this and, come on, when someone finally reads my masterpiece, they’ll be blown away!”
Except that you’re wrong.
The part that’s tough, the part that makes a lot of first-time writers grimace (and makes some give up and quit outright), is when you hit that first set of reactions to your work… and realize that you’ve got a long way to go. So where do you get reactions that can really help you move forward?
Early readers.
And by early readers I don’t mean your Mom or your best friend, but people who will be willing to give you hard truths about what you’ve written. People who will challenge you to do better. My early readers taught me several major things that I’m going to share with you. Maybe you’ll recognize them in your own work?
Sentence Flow and Word Choice
I’m not going to say that every sentence I write is a masterpiece in terms of structure and rhythm. Probably few of the sentences are. But having someone early on point out what I was doing that “hit the ear” badly has helped me immensely in crafting more readable prose. It’s a benchmark I always keep in the back of my mind as I’m building up a sentence or paragraph, and one that I wish more published authors would think about.
In short, when writing a sentence, think about how the words flow together and sound. It might seem picky. It might seem like the sort of thing that you’d want to ignore with the excuse, “Hey, if my story is exciting enough, nobody will care about those little things.” But trust me on this. People will have trouble completing a book that has terrible sentence flow.
For example, if all the words in a sentence start with the letter S, the sentence will slow significantly and sound strange. Maybe you want to do that to emphasize the point of the sentence. But if you’re writing action, I’d take a different tact. And like any gimmick, doing it once might be clever, but doing it a lot will make you look like a bad writer.
Overall Plot “Tone”
This is an interesting one brought up by one of my early readers on a previous draft of Devil’s Hand. It resulted in major rewrites, all which contributed greatly to the improvement of the story.
The idea here is that you can imagine the ‘tone’ of your story kind of like a steady musical note. When the action goes up, the note is high-pitched and sets your nerves a little on-edge. When the story dips into sequel and quite reflection, the tone is calm and comfortable, but risks being boring if it goes on too long. Different genres and different types of stories might have their own ideal tone patterns, but the common problems to look out for are:
SQUEAL: A constant, high-pitched tone from the first chapter to the last. Too much action, buddy! All scene and no sequel. Even if you’re writing a screenplay for the next Crank movie, Statham needs to take a quiet moment to wash the blood off every once in a while.
HUM: A constant, calm tone. No conflict. This story is just poking along and nothing much is happening. It might be interesting or original or even important, but it’s still likely boring. Maybe okay if you’re writing certain types of literature that are more introspective, but you better know that’s what you’re after.
PSYCHO: A tone that’s all over the place. Four chapters are high-pitched, then suddenly calm and boring for eight chapters, then high-pitched again without any warning, and so on. You haven’t figured out the scene and sequel rhythm yet. There’s a certain expectation the reader has of falling into a story rhythm. For a master of doing this right, check out Cormac McCarthy.
Same Words Used Too Close Together
Sure, it’s easy to figure out that you just wrote, “He went down to the Department of Redundancy Department.” Redundancy usually jumps out at us. But a more insidious flaw is when we craft a paragraph, or even a whole page, where we keep using the same, unique word in a way that starts to stand out to the reader.
Now, don’t go running off and replace all your “he said”s with “he growled” and “he conjectured.” Note that I said “unique words.” Thinks like “he said” blend in and the reader doesn’t really read them so much as just absorbs them. What you really want is to watch out for how many times in a single page you’ve described the bald man’s pate. Or how often in two paragraphs you mention that the main character brought out his leather billfold. It’s a unique word or phrase that gives your prose some life. But too many times and it starts taking the reader away from the actual story.
So those are just three of the big ones that I struggle with and had early readers point out. Acting on that realization improved my novels tenfold. Take some of these considerations to heart and I promise your writing will improve. What other big-picture issues have early readers pointed out in your writing?
ABOUT THE AUTHOR
M. E. Patterson is an author of sci-fi, fantasy, horror, and thrillers, as well as an information technologist. He received an English/Fiction Writing degree from Virginia Tech, where he studied under nationally-recognized writers and poets. He has published short stories on RevolutionSF and his first manuscript for his book, Devil’s Hand, placed in the top five in the Writers’ League of Texas Manuscript Contest.
You can visit his website at http://devils-hand.com or his blog at http://blog.digimonkey.com.
Connect with him on Twitter at www.twitter.com/mepatterson or Facebook at http://on.fb.me/dhnovel.
ENTER THE CONTEST
Just comment on the post below and leave the first bit of your email address. You do need to be a NOR Newsletter / Fan Club subscriber to enter. USA Postage Only on shipped items. Ends - 11/25/2011
Check out the Night Owl Reviews digital magazine. It comes out monthly on the 15th and has exclusive content and interviews.
Quite an intersting post; I enjoyed reading it.
ReplyDeleteThanks,
Tracey D
booklover0226@
I really enjoy reading posts authors write about their craft. They are generally interesting and I learn from them - as I did this post. Is there a difference between an early reader and a beta reviewer (and if so, what)? Thanks.
ReplyDeleteDevil's Hand sounds different and interesting.
kacbooks@
Great discussion! I do some editing so I really enjoyed reading your comments! As an early reader, it's nice to know that the authors really do appreciate our feedback!
ReplyDeletesusanw28 (at) mindspring (dot) com
As a writer this post for me has been very informative. I feel these tips and points can be most helpful for any writer.
ReplyDeleteDarkhunterC@mail.com
i love to win the book sound interesting and will do good on the market
ReplyDeletedesithelbonde2msn.com
Thanks for those "words of wisdom." I've been an early reader for a few authors/friends who picked me because I can be brutally honest wihtout being overly harsh. It is hard to hear critiques esepcially early in a project - but if you find a person who has both a good grasp of grammar, syntax, etc. and can give useful constructive criticism, hold on to them! They're worth their weight in gold.
ReplyDeleteI'd love to read your book!
MJB
msmjb65@
You're not the only one who wishes more published authors would think about sentence flow and word choice. I won't name names, but even some authors that are on the best seller list are guilty of this. Then there are the best selling author's who sell millions of books world wide, that also struggle with plot tone. I think they just try to hard to get books out, trying to live up to their reputation, that the book ends up being a big snore, or is just way too over the top. What an honest piece of writing this is, not to mention interesting and helpful to up and coming authors. I wish more authors would blog like this. Instead, you've got authors that sell 50 million books world wide who either hire someone to write their blogs for them, or you've got the Indie authors that blame the big publishing houses for all their issues. Yes, that is an over the top remark, but sadly, it is true for a tiny percentage.
ReplyDeleteI will be honest and admit that I'd never heard of you or Devil's Hand before this contest, but after reading this post, I will definitely be reading it, whether I win the contest or not.
willowbug@
I enjoyed reading your interesting post!cheryllynne@
ReplyDeleteI learned a lot reading this post. Thank you so much.
ReplyDeletemusicalfrog@
I agree with what you say. And I enjoyed reading your post. I would love to read your book. I read everything I can get my hands on, horror, romance, sci- fi, mystery, paranormal, comedy, everything.
ReplyDeleteI have over 1,000 physical books and 3,000 e-books so yes I love to read!!
tammi.hagberg@sbcglobal.net
Thanks for all the great comments and especially thanks to Night Owl Reviews for letting me guest post! :)
ReplyDeleteTo answer one commenter's question:
I break my early readers into two groups: alpha (or early, whatever you want to call it) and beta. The idea, for me at least, is the alpha readers are people that I'm not ashamed to show terrible, awful garbage to. My alpha readers tell me, "Matt, this chapter just ain't working. It bored me to tears. Here's why..."
By the time I get to beta readers, I'm hopefully handing them a pretty good book and looking for things more like, "Matt, this chapter was a lot of fun, but you mentioned the dog's name was Tiger even though two chapters ago he was called Trigger." ... or ... "This chapter is good, but it could be better with another sentence or two of Joe's feelings about the murder."
Great post. I've learned something new.
ReplyDeleteorelukjp0.......
Interesting and informative post!
ReplyDeletePat Cochran
p-cochran@
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteTake two! Thank you for being open to criticism, it's a win-win situation because many readers such as myself are reluctant to finish reading poorly flowing books. My impression is that this will become even more of an issue as more authors self-publish. Good luck with the new release!
ReplyDeleteThank you, your post was very informative and very interesting!
ReplyDeleteterrndeb@
He sounds like an author to be added to my list of authors to check out.
ReplyDeleteThe winner is: musicalfrog
ReplyDeletethanks for sponsoring this giveaway!
ReplyDeleteThe book arrived today! Wow thank you so much.
ReplyDeleteDefinitely great to know - I don't think I could ever be an author so I will settle for being a die-hard bookworm - dealing with constructive criticism or any criticism at all is tough for me!
ReplyDeleteFelicia
mrschopchop@...